Every small business owner asks this eventually. Here's the honest comparison from someone who actually builds all three.
Quick answer
- Squarespace — best if you have decent design instincts and want to update the site yourself weekly
- Wix — best if you want the most flexibility and don't mind fiddling
- Custom design (like SiteInADay) — best if you want a real designer's craft, a locked scope, and to not touch it again
Everyone will tell you their choice was best. They're all wrong — the right answer depends on you.
Squarespace — the honest breakdown
What Squarespace is genuinely good at
- Beautiful templates that don't look templated when you strip them back
- Genuinely intuitive editor if you have design instincts
- Integrated everything: email marketing, booking, e-commerce, blog, all included
- Fantastic mobile rendering out of the box
What Squarespace is not good at
- Load speed — consistently slower than competitors, hurts SEO
- Limited layout flexibility — you fight the grid, the grid wins
- Getting expensive fast: $22–$40/month base + extras stack up
- Custom code injection is limited
Real cost:
$22–$40/month + 15–25 hours of your time. If you value your time at $50/hour, that's $750–$1,250 in hidden labor cost before you launch.
Wix — the honest breakdown
What Wix is good at
- Most flexible editor of any drag-and-drop builder
- Massive template library
- Wix ADI (their AI) does a genuinely decent first draft
- Cheaper than Squarespace at the entry tier
What Wix is not good at
- Templates are locked once selected — can't switch without rebuilding
- Ads on the free tier make you look amateur
- SEO tools are worse than Squarespace out of the box
- Sites can look busy or messy without design discipline
Real cost:
$14–$29/month + 20–40 hours of your time (more because the flexibility means more decisions).
Custom design (productised) — the honest breakdown
What custom is good at
- Unique design that reflects your actual brand
- Fastest load times possible (no bloated builder overhead)
- Best SEO foundations because a designer optimises everything
- Zero of your time — you hand over info, get a finished site
- Locked scope means predictable outcome
What custom is not good at
- You can't rebuild sections yourself easily (though you can edit text)
- If you want an entirely different design in 3 months, you're paying again
- Higher upfront cost, though total-cost-of-ownership evens out over 12 months
Real cost:
$197 (SiteInADay Starter) or up to $2,250 for a bespoke agency build. Plus 12 months free hosting. Add the $27/month Care Plan if you want ongoing edits handled for you.
Which one should you actually pick?
Pick Squarespace if: you have design instincts, you want to update the site yourself, and you value flexibility over speed.
Pick Wix if: you're on a tight budget, you're happy fiddling, and you don't mind spending weekends on it.
Pick custom (SiteInADay or agency) if: your time is worth more than $50/hour, you want it done properly the first time, and you'd rather focus on your business than your website.
Ready?
Order SiteInADay — $197 AUD, live in 24 hours →
Or apply for one of our 5 free monthly builds: The Founding 5.
0 comments